Now I don't want to call Mr. Gibson a liar, especially a deliberate one, and especially a deliberate liar who gets a lot of capital gains in a year and makes more than the $250k. But he misrepresented how capital gains act after changes in the tax rate according to FactCheck.org "".
Fact check.org explains that though the moderator was technically correct about capital gains taxes returns going up immediately following cuts to the capital gains tax...
Excerpt FactCheck.org "Taking Liberties in Philadelphia " (scroll down to "Capital Gains Misinformation"):
Gibson’s claim is partially right. Cutting the capital gains tax rate does stimulate at least a temporary, short-term increase in revenue by giving owners of appreciated assets (such as real estate or stocks) an incentive to sell them and turn their paper profits into cash. The boost in capital gains income can offset the loss to the government from the lower rate.
The long-term revenue effects of changes to the capital gains tax rate are less certain, however. For example, in 1990, when Congress was considering a 30 percent cut in the capital gains tax rate, Congress’ Joint Committee on Taxation and the Treasury’s Office of Tax Analysis both attempted to compute the revenue effects of the cuts. OTA predicted at $12 billion increase in revenue over five years. JCT predicted an $11 billion loss over five years. Academic studies have produced similarly conflicting results.
The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office concluded in 2002 that cuts to the capital gains tax rate "may not be enough to produce additional receipts over a long period" but "may do so over a few years." Similarly, Jane Gravelle, a tax policy specialist with the Congressional Research Service, says that the empirical evidence on capital gains tax rate changes "does not clearly point to a specific response and revenue cost," adding that the latest research shows "more modest" change than economists had previously thought.
tags: democratic debate charles gibson
links: digg this del.icio.us technorati reddit